By Matt Grager
While many people think of homelessness as a mainly urban issue, here in Seattle it has taken to the suburbs as well. Across Lake Washington, minutes east of Seattle, is a collection of tents and tarps, raised on wooden pallets and pitched on the grounds of Temple B’nai Torah in Bellevue, one of the Northwest’s wealthiest cities.
Tent City 4 is a community of homeless people that provides a short-term solution to street living for up to 100 at a time on Seattle’s eastside since 2004. Churches or synagogues invite the community to stay on their grounds for 90 days at a time before they move onto another location. However, as with many aspects of homelessness, the politics around it are sticky.
On one side, the neighborhoods that Tent City moves to inevitably raise an uproar and some file law suits in fear that Tent City will bring with it crime and substance abuse. In their corner are a few local organizations aimed at stopping Tent City, the foremost of which is Tent City Solutions, which, contrary to their name provide no solutions to the issue of homelessness or alternatives to Tent City on their website, other than several calls to simply disband it.
Tent City, though, screens its residents before they can move in, including a warrant check, and is completely substance- and alcohol-free under penalty being forced out of the community. They allow police to come through at any and all times and have strict code of conduct aimed at alleviating the neighborhood concerns. They are also not the stereotypical derelict. Many are couples, most are working, and some are families, all for whom the shelter system and street living are not a reasonable option.
“People always say they need to educate the homeless,” said Leo Rhodes, resident and one of the founders of Tent City 4. “But I think it’s the non-homeless who need to be educated. They need to see the realities.”
Statistics brought forth by those on either side of the issue are constantly contradicting. Tent City Solutions claims a rise in crime in the areas where the community stays. SHARE/WHEEL, the sponsoring organization for Tent City, says that because of the residents who often walk the surrounding area, crime actually goes down. SHARE/WHEEL also estimates that because the Tent City provides a safe space to store belongings and 24-hour access, 90 percent of their residents work at least part time – well above the national statistic of 20 percent.
But to get to the reality of Tent City, it is important to move past the statistics. According to Rhodes, one of the benefits of the community is its interaction with their non-homeless neighbors. Their report with their neighbors has been so positive that they have returned to many churches for a second stay with little to no neighborhood resistance.
This writer, who has lived in an area hosting Tent City 4, twice, has seen no evidence of negative impact, and was impressed by the extent to which the Tent City goes to keep cordial relations with its neighbors.
In one neighborhood a woman complained that the number of residents waiting at the local bus stop may force kids to ride their bikes in the street around them. Tent City agreed to only have residents wait at the stop for ten minutes–a minute longer and they would walk and wait at a stop inconveniently further down the street, again under penalty of expulsion.
While at the Temple B’nai Torah, the municipal government wanted to know what the residents would do in case of a fire, as they are outside but surrounded by a flimsy chainlink fence. Apparently their simple answer of “push the fence over and walk out,” wasn’t adequate. When they arrived, a section of the fence had been removed and in its place was a door frame and emergency exit door, locked on the outside, complete with the panic push bar, leading from outdoors to outdoors.
Clearly, a mobile camp of tents is not a long-term solution to the problem of homelessness. But it does provide a temporary solution for its residents and demonstrates that there is no need to be pushed to the margins of our society.
Tent City 4 will be moving out of the Temple B’nai Torah on August 4, to Mercer Island, Washington. The city of Mercer Island currently has a law suit filed to block the move.





















